Last October, the first public reports of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) using the Indianapolis International Airport runways for detainee flights were released. Now, with Thanksgiving break approaching, some Butler students have decided to cut down on travel as a preemptive measure while others view the reports as a method of inducing unnecessary fear.
Jane Doe, a pseudonym for a student granted anonymity by The Butler Collegian due to fears regarding safety, moved to the United States from Venezuela in 2021 and is one student currently avoiding travel. She shared how the presence of ICE in Indianapolis has affected her personal life.
“People that I know and that I’ve hung out with have gotten deported,” Doe said. “They are people who are here to work, and they were not even here illegally. They were doing their paperwork, they were studying, they were applying [for] scholarships.”
Doe shared a story about when a friend of her mother’s, also from Venezuela and awaiting asylum, was apprehended by ICE on his way to work. Doe explained that asylum-seeking immigrants — which is the case of many Venezuelan immigrants that she knows of — are not here illegally, but rather waiting on a status update. When her mother’s friend was detained, ICE allegedly denied the asylum request and issued a deportation order. Since this incident, Doe and her mother have been taking more precautions.
“I have not been traveling at all, and that has been the biggest thing,” Doe said. “I don’t go close to any type of airports. I used to travel like five to six times per year, not anymore.”
In regards to Butler’s international student community, Doe mentioned Bobbie Gibson, director of International Student Services, as someone who students stay in touch with about their travels.
Gibson did not express concern for the international students she works with regarding ICE’s presence in Indianapolis, but said that there is one piece of paper — a form called I-94 — that she does ask students to keep with them while they are here. She also mentioned that some of the international students will be traveling over Thanksgiving break.
“We have a broad range of students,” Gibson said. “I’m sure I have students who are very concerned, but not concerned enough to come to me. I am not worried for them, not at this point. One of the things I tell my students is, you don’t need to panic until I panic, okay? And right now I’m not panicking.”
Ailym Soto Sequeda, a senior healthcare and business major and Global Connection Leader (GCL), said she feels like recent news and social media documentation of ICE do their part in making people aware of the situation, but can also increase the fear factor.
“On campus, I guess [international students] just are concerned,” Soto Sequeda said. “They ask, ‘Where can we go?’ and what parts to stay away from. It shouldn’t be a common thing to ask because you’re in America, you’re supposed to feel safe in your community.”
Doe believes it is important for students at Butler to be aware of their surroundings and do their part in educating themselves about what is going on in their community.
“I think it’s more about human rights [than being a political issue],” Doe said. “I would encourage people to form their own opinion and think about whether they think this is right or wrong, based on their own values and beliefs.”

