Men’s soccer season recap: Building the foundation

Coming into the 2026 season, no one knew what to expect from the Butler men’s soccer team. The team was starting from scratch with a brand new head coach, Ian Sarachan, and 18 new players added to the roster.

By the time the season wrapped up after a 3-1 loss to Xavier, the Bulldogs finished 3-9-3 overall and 3-3-2 in Big East Conference play. Despite the subpar record, the team ended up finishing fourth in the Big East Midwest Division and only missed out on the conference tournament by a single point.

The beginning of the season was rough for the Bulldogs, as they scored only three goals in seven games. They opened the 2026 season with a loss to Northern Illinois. They added more losses in tight road games at Indiana, Western Michigan and Dayton. They also were defeated by Memphis, Lindenwood and had a tie against Bradley.

Midway through the season, Butler was 0-6-2 and had the lowest winning percentage in the Big East.

Junior forward Brendan Cunningham believes staying confident through the early losing streak came down to trusting the process and leaning on each other.

“I think for us, it was just about staying with each other and continuing to build on the principles we came into preseason with,” Cunningham said. “We knew that eventually things were gonna click. We just knew we had to be patient and give ourselves time to allow those things to cook. Once they did, it was easy to stay confident from there.”

Building chemistry with so many new faces added to the team took work off the field before it showed up on game day. Redshirt junior goalkeeper Brooks Boersma, who played every minute this fall after not playing his first three years on the team, said getting the group on the same page began in the summer.

“I think it started early getting everyone on campus in July and trying to hang out with the guys outside of soccer,” Boersma said. “I think that’s the best way to build trust and communication with the guys first, and then just as time goes [on], communication and trust will come along with it.”

Stepping into the starting goalkeeper role was a big adjustment for  Boersma, both physically and mentally. He not only had to keep his body fueled and rested to compete in 15 straight games, but he also had to learn how to shake off the tough moments in the goal and reset for the next game.

“The biggest mental [adjustment] would be mistakes, what happens when you get scored on and how you can bounce back from one bad game where you let in five goals to a game where you have a clean sheet against the Big East champions,” Boersma said. “The biggest [challenge] is how you can bounce back from an error to set yourself up for a good game the next day.”

In the middle of the season, graduate defender Lou-Kent Bosc said he still believed the Bulldogs were going to do something good and prove they could compete in the Big East.

The turnaround happened when Butler won its first game of the season against Villanova. First-year forward Finn Moran said celebrating this win with the team in the locker room was the best moment of the whole season.

“We worked so hard throughout the whole season [so] we were really dying for that winning feeling,” Moran said.

Earlier this season, Moran talked about the importance of stacking “small victories” that helped him push through the transition of the difference of collegiate soccer. All the work he put in turned into a huge first season for Moran, who ended up leading the team in goals and assists. This season, Moran recorded four goals, four assists and earned All-Big East Second Team honors.

“Before I really started to get going, I was extremely close and I felt like it was coming,” Moran said. “I was getting in the box and getting the ball and once I started going, it just kept going.”

Moran credited his teammates, especially veterans like Bosc, and having a consistent starting lineup for helping him feel more confident in making plays. Cunningham also felt a similar shift in his own game from August to November, attributing it to not overthinking and beginning to play out of instinct.

“As time went on, I feel like I just got more and more comfortable and was able to play well with the guys around me,” Cunningham said.

Even though their overall record was not what they wanted it to be when the season ended, nobody on the team ever gave up.

“If you look at us training in October and November, you would never assume that we had the record that we did,” Boersma said. “That’s a testament to how everyone perceived the season, where it might not have gone the way we wanted it, but it laid the groundwork for hopefully a good season next year.”

Cunningham also was impressed with how the team stuck together, even during tough stretches of the season.

“We gave ourselves everything to play for up until the last game, so I think there’s a lot of good to take from the year,” Cunningham said.

Since their season is now finished, the Bulldogs pay attention to what lies ahead. While Butler will miss its graduating seniors and fifth-years, there are now opportunities for returning players, such as Cunningham, to step into bigger leadership roles and work hard this offseason. Players like Moran are focused on getting stronger, faster and continuing to build chemistry with teammates going forward. Boersma also confirmed he will use his final year of eligibility next year.

After rebuilding this season, the Bulldogs are excited for what is to come in Coach Sarachan’s second year.

“I’m extremely proud of the way the guys stuck together and fought through,” Cunningham said. “There’s very few teams around the country that would have stuck together the way we did.”