GRAYSON PRATHER | STAFF REPORTER
In the 13th minute of the first half, Butler junior Caleb Postlewait scored on a penalty kick that would prove to be the final goal of the contest.
Butler had numerous other chances, including a header by Joey Bastian in extra time that went just wide of the goal, but was unable to convert.
Goalkeeper Eric Dick saved a penalty kick in the 93rd minute to preserve the tie. Dick saved seven shots in the contest.
Butler was outshot 17-6.
Butler will return to the Butler Bowl on Tuesday night, to face Valparaiso at 7:00 p.m.