Women’s soccer season recap: An upward climb

Despite finishing seventh in the Big East conference standings, the Bulldogs had a successful season marked by multiple Athlete of the Week awards, a winning record and a strong team dynamic. The team finished 2-4-4 in conference and 7-6-5 overall.

The Dawgs entered the season as a young, new team. The program recruited 10 first-years and three transfers. Last spring, the Bulldogs worked hard to create a positive and well-bonded team dynamic. When the first-years arrived, junior defender Gemma Gillespie knew it was important to maintain the team chemistry they had already established. Gillespie wanted to be a strong mentor for the younger players. As a center back, she worked closely with first-years Kensey Teffner and Chrissy Graves.

“[Graves] and [Teffner] played center back with me,” Gillespie said. “They did a very good job of being open-minded and receptive to feedback, whether it be from our coaching staff or me. It’s a learning and experience-based position. [They are put] in game situations where they are expected to be high-level experienced players. It’s super exciting to see where they’re going to go with that [next season].”

Sophomore goalkeeper Addison Ash had similar experiences with the recruits. She saw the first-years step onto the field ready to do whatever it took to positively impact the team.

“The 10 [first-years] all came in with just a hunger and a want to play and get better,” Ash said. “Credit to all of them because they came in and instead of being scared or held back, they all stepped right in and made a difference. I think [one thing] that [helped us] is we have such a young team and there isn’t a big age gap.”

Senior midfielder Isabella Ayau was one of the 13 new players entering the 2026 season. She transferred from the University of San Francisco to Butler last spring. As a senior and transfer student, she had a unique perspective on the season.

“I am the oldest on the team and the only senior as well,” Ayau said. “It felt like I was a freshman all over again. This is my fourth season [of college soccer], but it’s different because it’s not the same preseason. The entire fall [season] was a different beast. I felt like a first-year, but at the same time, I was like, ‘Wait, I’m actually not; it’s my fourth year.’ It was really interesting to transition.”

Ayau is taking advantage of her fifth year of eligibility. She is encouraged by the steps the team took this year and is looking forward to watching how the team culture continues to develop further.

“Having that fifth year is really exciting,” Ayau said. “I’m excited to see what this team can do. We are losing one [player], but we still have a strong foundation of what we built this past year. I’m excited to see where this team goes.”

A season highlight for the Bulldogs includes a 3-2 road win over DePaul. In this match, Gillespie scored two timely goals in the second half to secure the win, earning her the title of Big East Defensive Player of the Week. She reflects on the camaraderie she felt from her team in this moment.

“I’ve never really been in the scoring position,” Gillespie said. “To see [the team] band around me was super cool. It gives me a lot more motivation to do [good] for my teammates whenever they’re having their own individual successes, whether it be as blatant as scoring a goal or coming back from an injury.”

Another big game for the Bulldogs was their 1-0 win over Villanova. Heading into the match, the Wildcats were undefeated for nearly a year. Their streak began when they tied Butler on Nov. 1, 2025, and ended with the Dawgs’ victory on Oct. 24, 2026.

“I think that [match] was one that we weren’t expected to win,” Ash said. “We had been battling some ups and downs, whether through individual players, injuries or as a team, and not getting results that we should have, which was super frustrating. I think beating Villanova really showed us what we could do and the potential we have as a team.”

Other Big East awards went to Ash and Chloe Brecht throughout the season. Ash received Athlete of the Week recognition three times throughout the season. She was also selected for the All-Big East Third Team. Brecht, a junior midfielder, received first-team All-Big East recognition and was also Athlete of the Week twice throughout the season.

Ash and Brecht played together in the offseason with Indy Eleven. This opportunity allowed them to learn more about each other outside of the college atmosphere.

“[Brecht and I] played [at] Indy Eleven together this summer, and it was a super cool experience,” Ash said. “I got to get close to her and the player she really was outside of soccer. Her work ethic is insane in school and in sports. She’s someone that will spend an extra few hours in the locker room if that means helping someone out. I think that the small things that she did for others really added up. She’s truly a one-of-a-kind person and player.”

Despite the highs, the Dawgs experienced some lows as well. Two tough road games were lost; one was a 2-1 loss to Creighton. The last time the Bulldogs lost to the Blue Jays was in September 1993. The other match was a 5-0 defeat against Providence, which was the largest loss of the season.

Gillespie and the rest of the team have their sights set on revenge next year.

“We had 13 girls who had never played in this conference,” Gillespie said. “We have chips on our shoulders. I can already tell you, we’re coming for Creighton, we’re coming for Providence. Those games will be really fun.”

Overall, this season gave the team the opportunities to integrate their recruits and establish a positive team culture. The players have all had the chance to experience collegiate-level competition and know what needs to be done to come back better and stronger next season.

“In the offseason, [we are] focusing on staying together, especially [with] players coming back from injuries,” Ash said. “I think the progress we did make was really good, but the next step forward is, ‘How do we make a bigger impact next year?’”