Butler women’s soccer outlasts Providence in double overtime thriller

Freshman forward Caitlyn DiSarcina looks for a teammate against Cleveland State on Sept. 3. DiSarcina’s goal against Providence gave Butler the 2-1 win on Oct. 1.

COLLIN PERRY | ASST SPORTS EDITOR | ccperry@butler.edu

The Butler women’s soccer team needed double overtime to defeat Providence College 2-1 on Oct. 1.

Junior forward Paige Monaghan scored the game’s first goal in the 12th minute. Butler lead 1-0 going into halftime on Monaghan’s fourth goal of the season.

Providence’s Katie Day scored the game tying goal off of a Butler deflection in the 73rd minute. It was Butler’s first goal allowed since Aug. 20 against Ohio University, their second game of the season.

Butler’s game winning goal came in the 108th minute. With under two minutes left in the second overtime, Monaghan crossed a pass on the left side. Freshman forward Caitlyn DiSarcina knocked the pass into the back of the net for the game winner.

Redshirt sophomore Hannah Luedtke and freshman Leonie Doege split time at goalkeeper. Luedtke made three saves and shutout the Friars in the first half. Doege played the rest of the match, making five saves while allowing her first goal of the season.

Providence outshot the Bulldogs 18-11 in the match. Monaghan led the team in shots with five and finished with a goal and an assist. DiSarcina and junior defender Madison Toth added a pair of shots.

Butler moves to 9-1-2 on the season and 2-0-1 in conference play. The Bulldogs play Xavier University at 7 p.m. on Oct. 5 at the Sellick Bowl.


The Butler Collegian E-Newsletter

We get it—you’re busy. But the news waits for no one, so stay up-to-date by subscribing to the Collegian’s free e-newsletter. Every Wednesday, you’ll get great coverage of Butler news and events delivered right to your inbox. Click here to sign up.


Advertise with us

The Butler Collegian website receives about 12,000 views per week, and 600 papers are distributed across Butler University each week. If you are interested in advertising with The Butler Collegian, please visit our advertising page or contact Editor-in-Chief Caleb Denorme (cdenorme@butler.edu).


Send us a letter

Send us your letters to the email listed below complete with your full name and affiliation with Butler University. Please keep your letter under 500 words. All letters may be edited by The Butler Collegian’s editorial staff for style and grammar. collegian@butler.edu.


Have an idea?

Is there something you want to see covered in The Butler Collegian? Let us know through this tipline!