‘127 Hours’ is gritty, real portrayal of life-or-death decision

There’s nothing like a good amputation scene.

Danny Boyle’s (“Slumdog Millionaire,” “28 Days Later”) new film, “127 Hours,” is the story of adventurer Aron Ralston and the perfect expedition gone wrong.

For those who don’t remember, Ralston was hiking alone in Utah when a boulder shifted, pinning him to a canyon wall. He eventually, of his own accord, broke the bones in his arm and then amputated it to rappel out of the canyon and walk to find help.

Ralston is played by James Franco, who goes solo for almost the entire movie with little interruption.

Most of the time the people that appear next to the star are passersby, namely two lost hikers (Kate Mara and Amber Tamblyn).

As Ralston begins to fade in and out of total consciousness, he begins to hallucinate about his past and other aspects of his life. It is not clear to the viewer what his visions mean until the latter part of the film.

Franco does a great job playing Ralston. He shows a lot of dimension within the character. While critics may applaud Franco for his performance, which he deserves, Boyle deserves a lot more credit. The world’s greatest actor could have been Ralston, and if the director was visionless, it still would have been garbage.
Boyle pulls it off.

The film comes packaged in a gleaming sheen. It’s a lot like a really bright candy wrapper, chalk full of vibrant colors. At the same time it can be dark, foreboding and stormy, but that’s to be expected—the movie is about a man who has to do the unthinkable to survive.

Speaking of the unthinkable, the amputation scene was done very well. I’m pretty squeamish when it comes to gore like that, so I was not looking forward to the up-close shots of the dismemberment.

However, Boyle made it seem realistic without making the audience throw up. It is best not to give away all of it, but imagine if Franco was playing the grown-up version of “Operation,” with real pain.

Everything about it is compelling, including the amputation, but the film really didn’t redefine my list of favorite movies this year. “127 Hours” is an excellent film, but viewers only need to see it once.


The Butler Collegian E-Newsletter

We get it—you’re busy. But the news waits for no one, so stay up-to-date by subscribing to the Collegian’s free e-newsletter. Every Wednesday, you’ll get great coverage of Butler news and events delivered right to your inbox. Click here to sign up.


Advertise with us

The Butler Collegian website receives about 12,000 views per week, and 600 papers are distributed across Butler University each week. If you are interested in advertising with The Butler Collegian, please visit our advertising page or contact Editor-in-Chief Caleb Denorme (cdenorme@butler.edu).


Send us a letter

Send us your letters to the email listed below complete with your full name and affiliation with Butler University. Please keep your letter under 500 words. All letters may be edited by The Butler Collegian’s editorial staff for style and grammar. collegian@butler.edu.


Have an idea?

Is there something you want to see covered in The Butler Collegian? Let us know through this tipline!