Throwback uniforms in sports are overrated. The uniforms got replaced for a reason and the colors do not blend together as modern uniforms do now.
The more infamous throwback uniforms include the Green Bay Packers’ 1923 uniforms, the Pittsburgh Steelers’ 1934 “Bumblebee” uniforms or the Philadelphia Eagles’ 1934 uniforms.
Although some modern day uniforms have been taken over by minimalism, it is better than a throwback because at least they are the current uniform. Teams need to stop living in the past and focus on the present.
Colors are outdated
Color schemes make or break a good uniform combination and when the colors are too bright, the uniform does not look as nice as a darker color.
This is mostly a problem in the NFL with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Seattle Seahawks and Denver Broncos, but also in the NBA with the Memphis Grizzlies’ Vancouver jersey or the Detroit Pistons.
Sophomore marketing major Matt Shaw believes that the brand of the uniforms is a key to the difference in coloring in uniforms.
“It also comes down to the different brands that they work with like Reebok and Nike,” Shaw said. “Nike’s color palette would be more neon whereas Reebok’s is a darker color and also reflects the grittiness of football.”
Some teams are the opposite, going from dark uniforms to brighter like the Miami Dolphins and Jacksonville Jaguars, but those uniforms are still loved more than their current ones.
Sophomore environmental studies major Cole Kelly believes loving a specific color combination is a result of what you saw as a kid and what team you are a fan of.
“It depends on the fan base,” Kelly said. “I grew up watching the Patriots as a blue team [but] it’s cool bringing [the old uniforms back] on special games. As uniforms evolve today, it’s [nice for teams to come] out with new [designs].”
While the Dolphins and Jaguars’ current uniforms are brighter, they are taken over by minimalism but embrace present color schemes. Teams should not have bright orange as their primary color like the Buccaneers and Broncos did, they need darker colors.
Living in the past
Teams live in the past by wearing throwback uniforms. Organizations should focus on the present and not the past. Teams have current uniforms that fans become accustomed to. Why have current uniforms if you are not going to use them?
Shaw emphasizes that keeping the past around is fine as long as you do not get stuck in it.
“I think it’s better to embrace the past but also focus more on the future,” Shaw said. “Keeping traditions alive is what it really comes down to.”
Teams can have success in older uniforms and not as much in newer uniforms, but if you are still focused on the past, you will not be able to move forward as a franchise.
The New York Jets won their only Super Bowl in their throwback uniforms and now they are updating their uniforms left and right, trying to relive the glory days as the team owns the longest playoff drought in professional sports. The Buffalo Bills lost four straight Super Bowls in the 1990s wearing a red helmet which the franchise uses as a throwback today, but they are yet to reach the Super Bowl again.
The consistent championship contenders do not mess with their past, and that is why they have been successful in this decade.
Noah Huber, a junior international student and American studies major argues that rebranding is a good thing to focus on for the future and new team success.
“It makes sense that teams don’t use [old] colors in their current logo or uniforms,” Huber said. “The teams [had] success in the past and today’s teams are different from back then.”
If they were good uniforms, they would last
Uniforms that have stood the test of time are considered the best in sports, across different leagues from teams like the New York Yankees, Las Vegas Raiders, Kansas City Chiefs and the Chicago Blackhawks. If throwback uniforms were really that good, they would not have to be rebranded.
Kelly argues that a thing cannot be good-looking forever, even throwback uniforms.
“I don’t think there’s one thing that could be great forever because there’s going to be changing perspectives with time,” Kelly said. “With how the future is changing, they’re creating more and better [designs] on the uniforms which is cool to see.”
Teams that have rebranded their uniforms but kept the similar design do the rebrand right by keeping their old design but still incorporating the present with a good, modern uniform.
Culture
Teams that do not worry about their uniforms usually have had the most success over the years. All of the great franchises have not messed with frequently new uniforms and have just kept their simple designs as it helps with their brand identity.
The Chicago Bulls have never significantly changed their logo or uniforms, with the help of Michael Jordan, which has created a strong brand. Both the Yankees and Los Angeles Dodgers have recognizable baseball logos, while the Packers and Chicago Bears provide football’s most iconic uniforms.
Shaw feels that building a culture and having tradition is good for a team, and they do not need a throwback uniform to prove that.
“It’s cool to update and add to the jerseys for events that happen like patches for memorials,” Shaw said. “I think keeping tradition alive and the way the [uniform] was originally designed is the best way [to have a culture].”
Some players follow the “look good, play good” idea where looking good on the field will translate into success, while others simply just want to win.
Huber thinks that marketing plays a role in throwback uniforms and is a reason teams wear them.
“Throwback uniforms are like marketing,” Huber said. “[When they] bring them out it’s a big deal and that’s why they’re so popular. If they were the normal uniforms over time they wouldn’t be that popular.”
Teams can hang up banners and put players’ numbers into the rafters to keep their history alive, but throwback uniforms do not do the same because new players are wearing the history.
Exceptions
There are only a few exceptions to wearing throwback uniforms. Throwback uniforms might have a use during a commemorative season, such as celebrating a championship from the early years of a franchise or going back to an expansion team’s roots during an anniversary.
In the NFL, teams should only be allowed to wear a throwback uniform twice, once at home and once on the road. The MLB, NBA and NHL do not have a crazy throwback problem, but if a team does have a throwback, they should not be worn more than a modern alternate uniform.
Throwback uniforms are exactly that: a throwback. When teams stop wearing their old jerseys just for nostalgia, they will be moving a step in the right direction.

